People Pleasing and Guilt: Do You Have Eldest Daughter Syndrome?


Are you the eldest daughter in your family? Do you often find yourself trying to please everyone and feeling guilty when you can not? If so, you might be experiencing what some refer to as “Eldest Daughter Syndrome.” This phenomenon, although not officially recognized as a medical condition, describes a set of common traits and behaviors often seen in the firstborn daughters. Let’s get to know more about it. 

What is Eldest Daughter Syndrome?

Eldest Daughter Syndrome refers to a pattern of behavior commonly seen in firstborn daughters. These daughters often take on a caretaking role from a young age, feeling responsible for their younger siblings and sometimes even for their parents. This sense of responsibility can lead to a strong tendency toward people-pleasing and a deep-seated feeling of guilt when they can not meet everyone’s expectations.

Traits of Eldest Daughter Syndrome

In her TikTok video, licensed marriage and family therapist Kati Morton identifies eight traits commonly associated with Eldest Daughter Syndrome:

  • An Intense Feeling of Responsibility

Oldest daughters often feel a strong sense of duty and responsibility.

  • People-Pleasing

They try hard to make everyone happy, often putting others’ needs before their own.

  • Difficulty Setting Boundaries

Saying no and setting limits can be challenging for them.

  • Worrying and Anxiety

They might struggle with high levels of anxiety.

  • Overachievement

They are often very ambitious and hardworking.

  • Resentment Toward Siblings and Family

They may feel burdened and resentful due to their responsibilities.

  • Difficulties in Adult Relationships

They might struggle to manage relationships as adults.

  • Struggling with Guilt

When they can not meet high expectations, they may feel very guilty.

Why Do Eldest Daughters Feel This Way?

Family dynamics are important. Parents might unknowingly give more responsibility to the oldest child, expecting them to set a good example for their siblings. This can make the oldest daughter believe she always has to be strong, capable, and selfless. Society and culture also add pressure on girls and women to be caretakers.

Julia Rohrer, a personality psychologist, says older siblings usually have more responsibilities because they are older. This is even more true for girls, who often face extra expectations due to their gender. In many families, chores and caregiving tasks are still mostly done by women. These factors can make the oldest daughter feel overwhelmed and pressured.

Impact on Mental Health

The pressure to constantly please and the guilt associated with falling short can take a toll on mental health. Eldest daughters might experience anxiety, stress, and even depression. They might also struggle with low self-esteem, feeling that they are never good enough. These mental health struggles can persist into adulthood, affecting their personal and professional lives.

Beth Filippo, a mother of three from Illinois, shared her experience of growing up as the eldest daughter. She felt a constant sense of responsibility for her family, beyond just caring for them. She described it as a mix of guilt and obligation, knowing that reliability often rested solely on her shoulders.

Managing People-Pleasing and Guilt

Recognizing this pattern is the first step to handling these behaviors. Here are some easy and helpful tips:

  • Set Boundaries

Learn to say no without feeling guilty. Setting healthy boundaries is important for your well-being.

  • Practice Self-Care

Make time for yourself. Engage in activities that you enjoy and that help you relax and recharge.

  • Challenge Negative Thoughts

Work on identifying and challenging the negative thoughts that fuel your people-pleasing and guilt. Cognitive-behavioral techniques can be particularly helpful.

  • Communicate Openly

Have open and honest conversations with your family about how you feel. They might not realize the pressure you are under and could be more supportive than you expect.

Meghan Klasic, a mom of three from Minnesota, shared her story of growing up as the only girl among seven siblings. She often acted like a second mom, helping with chores and taking care of her younger brothers. Her brothers even called her “mom junior” because she had so many responsibilities.

Eldest Daughter Syndrome is a real challenge for many women. The pressure to please others and the guilt that comes with it can be tough. But by understanding the causes and finding ways to manage them, you can live a more balanced life. If you see these traits in yourself, remember it is okay to put your needs first and ask for help. You are not alone, and taking care of yourself is just as important as taking care of others.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.